The Borden Axe Murders

In Fall River, Massachusetts, on August 4th, 1892, around 11:10 am. Lizzie Borden heard a strange noise from her house and rushed inside. She ran into the living room to find a horrible sight. She saw her father, Andrew Borden, dead on the sofa with a disfigured face with blood pouring out the side of his head. His eye was split cleanly in two, suggesting he was asleep while he was attacked, and his nose wasn’t there. He was still bleeding, which meant the attack was recent. He had 10-11 whacks in him from a hatchet like weapon.

A censored photo of Andrew’s body found in the living room

The maid heard from her quarters in the attic from Lizzie “Come down quick! Father’s dead! Somebody’s come in and killed him!” Despite this call for help, Lizzie refused the maid, Bridget Sullivan, access to the room, thinking it too painful for her to see her father dead. Bridgette soon came back with a neighbour.

They didn’t know where the stepmother was, Abby Durfee Gray. The last they heard of her was the maid saying that she went out with friends. Lizzie said “Oh Maggie (a nickname for Bridget)! I am almost sure I heard her come in. Check upstairs and see if she is there!” The neighbour and Bridgette soon moved upstairs and saw Lizzie’s stepmother, dead. Abby Durfee Gray had 18-19 strokes with the hatchet and was face down in the bedroom.

A photo of Grey’s body in the bedroom

It is believed to be the hatchet that killed them was the same one that killed Lizzie’s pigeons a few months prior. There was nothing stolen, nor was there any sign of a break in. The timing of the murders is very peculiar. According to forensics teams, Abby was murdered at around at around 9:00 and Andrew was murdered around 11:00, since Abby’s blood was dry and, Andrew’s was fresh and wet. The maid stated that Lizzie was wearing “an unstained blue dress.” Lizzie was tried for the murder but acquitted of all charges. The strange thing is is that in such a small 3 storey house, nothing was heard by anyone until by Lizzie at 11:10

Suspect #1: Lizzie Borden – Daughter of Andrew Borden and Step-Daughter of Abby Durfee Grey

Lizzie Borden

The primary suspect is Lizzie Borden. She claimed she was in the barn looking for lead sinkers. After the murder, there was a large sum of money given to her, approximately $10 million in modern times. Her answers at the trial contradicted each other such as the fact that she said she put on her father’s slippers before his nap but according to crime scene photos he was wearing boots. A friend of Lizzie’s, Alice, saw her burning a red dress saying that “there was paint on it.” This was not the same dress Bridget described. A local pharmacist claimed she was trying to buy potassium cyanide the day before the murders. This was dismissed in the trial due to the fact that there was just some bad food in the victims on the autopsy report and nothing more. During the trial, the victim’s skulls were admitted as evidence and Lizzie fainted when she saw them. After a year of planning and prepping for the trial, the police only had circumstantial evidence so couldn’t convict her. 90 minutes and she was off scot free. This theory is so popular that there is a rhyme to go with the murders.

Lizzie Borden took an axe, And gave her mother forty whacks.

When she saw what she had done, She gave her father forty-one.

Rhyme sung about the murders

After her mother died, Lizzie apparently latched onto her father as the centre of her life, becoming a bit of a daddy’s girl before he remarried, an event she felt betrayed by. She often took to petulantly calling Abby “Mrs Borden” and would often leave early at meal times. Mending the relationship with his daughter was clearly irrelevant to Andrew, as he was incredibly strict with Lizzie. Some writers have interpreted the relationship in various ways, extending to him being abusive, and perhaps even sexually abusive, with Elizabeth Engstrom taking a very Freudian approach, with Lizzie filling the sexual desire in Andrew after the death of her mother.

Some have viewed the Borden murders as a feminist liberation from an oppressive patriarchy. Some others have interpereted her as cold, calculating and even insufferable, far from a feminist icon she is sometimes portrayed to be. However, Rafia Zakaria of The Guardian drew comparisons between the relationship with Lizzie and Andrew Borden to the relationship between Ivanka and Donald Trump, who has often been very open about sexualising his eldest daughter, calling her “voluptuous”, a “great piece of ass” and saying that if she wasn’t his daughter, he’d marry her.

The real Lizzie would likely not have recognised herself in many of the books about her, and she certainly never admitted to having committed the murders. It is too bad that recent takes on her story have veered towards the lurid, for there is plenty of contemporary relevance to be found in the feminist appraisals of the story. The same Americans who may choose to pick up a book about her, or even venture to the house on Second Street for a tour, might perceive similar paradigms being played out in the White House, where, with her own office in the West Wing, a daughter plays a similar part to the hilt, with only minor variants from the Victorian script of gentle cajoling and subordination. All while glibly sidelining a stepmother.

Rafia Zakaria “The Lizzie Borden murder industry won’t die – but its feminism has”

Suspect #2: Bridget Sullivan – Maid to the Borden Family

Bridget Sullivan

Abby was very strict and sometimes described as mean to Sullivan. She was cleaning the outside of the house and the went to bed when she was awoken by Lizzie’s screams. Where she was sleeping was above where Abby was murdered. Experiments conducted on the house prove that you would be able to hear a thud from a floor below, a sound even more likely to be heard due to the fact that she said she was only half asleep.

Suspect #3 – John Vinnicum Morse – Uncle of Lizzie Borden, Brother of Lizzie Borden’s mother

John V. Morse

The theory of Morse being behind the murders was thought of by maths teacher Richard Little who wrote a book on the case called “Cold Case to Case Closed. Lizbeth Borden. ~My Story~” John was not seen from 9:00 until noon. His alibi is that he was down the road visiting a sick relative with the town doctor. However, that very same doctor was looking at the bodies at the time. Morse was sleeping in the room that Abby was found in. Also, Morse may have known about the will. We can tell from the following transcript from Lizzie:

Q: Did you know of your father making a will?

A: No sir, except I heard somebody say once there was one several years ago. That is all I ever heard.

Q: Who did you hear say so?

A: I think it was Mr Morse.

Q: What Morse?

A: Uncle John V Morse

Transcript from the trial

Little also states there was a failing livestock business run by Mr Morse. He also said that he killed the Borden’s with a meat clever, since he was a butcher.

Suspect #4 – Were Lizzie Borden and Bridget Sullivan Lesbian Lovers?

A still from “Lizzie”. Kristen Stewart is depicting Sullivan (left) and Chloe Sevigny is depicting Borden (right)

The fourth theory is 2 people at once. That is Lizzie and Bridget. Many a fan fiction claim that they had a romantic relationship and Abby discovered it. The back up for this theory is that Lizzie confessed she had a crush on a female actor later in life. However, this theory was adapted into the 2018 film “Lizzie” starring Kristen Stewart and Chloe Sevigny as Sullivan and Borden respectively, pushing the theory into the mainstream.

Ultimately, we will never know what happened that fateful day in Fall River. The Borden Murders remain unsolved to this day, but have become a defining staple of the Pre-War America.

Benedict Arnold’s Betrayal, the Southern Campaign and the End of the War

Still currently in charge of Philadelphia, Benedict Arnold had moved into Penn Mansion, which Clinton had used as his headquarters, and partied in the city with the Philadelphia Elite. He even married Peggy Shippen, a member of the Elite. However, this upper class in Philadelphia had also had parties with the British when they occupied the city. The city turned against Arnold, viewing him as a traitor. The state governor sent a letter to Washington, informing Arnold of his treasonous behaviour. Washington, who had originally saw Arnold as a “fighting general” and had supported him, denounced his behaviour. It was around this time Arnold planned to defect.

He requested that Washington put him in charge of West Point, where he would contact the British, offering the plans to the fort in exchange for a Brigadier General position in the British Army and a decent sum of cash. By the time the plans were discovered by the Americans, Arnold had already defected and set up base in the British occupied New York.

Benedict Arnold handing over the plans to the British

By 1780, the British were losing support for the war. Despite having taken parts of Massachusetts, the North had largely come to a stalemate. The British decided to switch up and focus more of their efforts on the largely British supporting South. They captured Savannah, Georgia and when the Americans and French tried to fight back, they were repelled and the British advanced to Augusta. They then captured Charleston, taking many prisoners. Now occupying the majority of Georgia and South Carolina, the pro-British Americans in the region against the people who had been harassing them for being pro-British.

In order to deal with the Southern offensive, James Madison sent down Horatio Gates, who they believed was the one responsible for the successful offensive at Saratoga, to Camden. Gates got in one battle at Camden and was absolutely annihilated. Washington then sent down the much more capable Nathaniel Greene. He split his army into two, distracting General Tarleton, and defeating them with ease. He then pulled up Cornwallis’ men through North Carolina, straining their supply line. Greene then crossed the Virginia border, gathered reinforcements and faced down the British at Guilford Courthouse, who were tired from having to slug around their heavy equipment. Eventually, the two sides clashed in close-quarters combat. Fearing loss, Cornwallis fired cannons into the struggle, many of which cut down his own men. The American forces retreated but the British, just like Bunker Hill, sustained significantly more losses.

Eventually, both sides were becoming tired of the war. With mutinies occurring in the American Army and the British running out of money, the French arrival was the fresh air that they needed to end the war. Cornwallis decided to consolidate his men in Yorktown, with the intention to take Virginia, which was the American’s main supply hub. Meanwhile, Clinton’s forces in New York received intercepted messages saying that Washington intended to do a frontal assault of New York. However, Washington and the French, Commanded by Rochambeau, were secretly moving their troops down to Yorktown. The French navy made quick work of the British ships in the area whilst the ground troops tightened their grip on the city, firing artillery at Cornwallis’ men. Cornwallis asked Clinton for assistance but it never came. After holding out for a month, Cornwallis surrendered, with 7,000 British troops captured.

A painting of Cornwallis’ surrender

Parliament had enough of the war. Whilst Britain still did hold New York, Charleston and Savannah, they decided that they must sue for peace. The Treaty of Paris was signed, which dictated that British troops must leave the 13 colonies, recognise US independence and give them territory up to the Mississippi River, whilst America agreed to pay any debts to Britain and stop discrimination against any American Royalists. The Spanish took Florida.

Washington retired, wishing his men a farewell, saying:

With a heart full of love and gratitude, I now take leave of you. I most devoutly wish that your latter days may be as prosperous and happy, as your former ones have been glorious and honorable.

Washington speaking to his officers, 1783
A painting of Washington bidding farewell to his officers

Eventually, the ever modest Washington was forced by the other founding fathers to take the role of leader of the country, deciding to name the office the humble title of President. Ultimately, Washington could have made the office into anything he wanted, whether it be a fascist dictatorship or an absolute monarchy. He instead decided to make the office a fairly elected, with a cabinet of advisors, as he knew that one man could not know everything. He would give annual speeches, talking about the state of the Nation. He claimed that the US should remain neutral in foreign politics and resigned the office after two 4 year long terms, knowing someone else had to eventually take the rains. Due to Washington’s carefulness, he made the office of President of the United States one of the most respected in the world.

Crossing the Delaware & French Assistance

Winter had fallen upon the war. Due to the severe losses, troop morale was low, so low that many ended up abandoning the army. British forces had spread throughout the New Jersey area and, while they partied, hired some German mercenaries to guard the Delaware River. However, due to their defences being low, Washington decided that now was the time to strike.

On Christmas, 1776, Washington made a dangerous crossing across the icy Delaware River. It was considered of upmost importance that the river be crossed so every soldier was armed, including officers and musicians who were given muskets. He marched down to Trenton the next morning and took out the mercenaries with ease. This victory sent a message of American power and that the war was far from lost for the Colonies.

A famous painting of Washington crossing the Delaware

British forces were sent south to deal with the armies but were quickly taken care of by Washington’s army, forcing Britain to back out of Southern New Jersey. The Americans set up camp in Morristown and waited out the winter.

The British had managed to capture the northern naval base of New Port, Rhode Island, and attempted to capturing Charleston, South Carolina. Because of this, Congress sent Benjamin Franklin to Paris, to convince the French to join the fight. Whilst the French were deciding, Franklin allegedly starting getting in casual relationships with Parisian women.

Furious that the Colonies had not been crushed, the British came up with a plan, to meet up Burgoyne’s army in Canada with Howe’s army in New York, splitting the Colonies in half down the Hudson Valley. Burgoyne managed to make it to Bennington but Howe had not joined the fight. He had instead gone down to Philadelphia, capturing the capital and forcing Congress to move to York. This left Burgoyne to deal with the ever increasing American force at Saratoga.

Once again, we encounter Benedict Arnold. He was in a dispute with Horatio Gates. Gates wanted to set up defensive positions and push back from there. Arnold wanted to lead an offensive charge against the British. Gates eventually vetoed the plan but Arnold went against his orders and sent a large force against the British, pushing them back to Canada. Horatio took all the credit and Arnold did not get a single mention.

Burgoyne and Howe were both pulled out of the country, leaving General Henry Clinton in New Jersey. In addition, the victory at Saratoga meant the French could finally join the war against the British. Despite this ally, American forces were once again beginning to lose hope in Washington’s leadership, as winter had once again set in. Soon, a Prussian General called Friedrich Stueben came along and fixed everything, properly training the American army in shooting, marching and other such things that the army desperately needed. Those who did not comply would be punished. After the winter of 1778, Washington was ready to take back the capital. But before he could, Clinton was ordered to move all his forces to New Jersey, due to the new threat from France, and allowed Philadelphia to fall back into American hands. Washington assigned Arnold to hold down Philadelphia and chased the British all the way back to New York.

The Declaration of Independence & The British Return

After forcing the British troops out of Boston, Washington decided to move his troops down the New York, believing that if the British were to return, they would come for there. Meanwhile, Thomas Paine, a political philosopher, wrote a pamphlet called “Common Sense”, wherein he advocated for independence from Britain. It spread across the nation and became one of the best selling American titles. This pamphlet brought the idea of independence into the mainstream, meaning that congress began considering it seriously. Thomas Jefferson wrote an official Declaration of Independence. On July 2nd, Congress voted unanimously in favour of independence, with the independence taking effect on July 4th. The United States of America was born.

A painting of the signing of the Declaration of Indpendence

Due to viewing this declaration of independence as treason, King George sent 130 warships down to New York with 25,000 soldiers for a ground invasion. They set up camp on Staten Island whilst the Americans set up on Brooklyn Heights. However, the British did not attack, instead allowing the American’s nerves to wear down. After an artillery barrage, the British hit hard, having one half of their army attack Washington’s men from the front, while the other half looped from the back and flanked them. The American forces ended up being pushed back to the East River.

Between a rock and a hard place, Americans began to believe that the war was already lost. However, the British decided to entrench themselves around the Continental Army as a thick fog set in, allowing the Americans to cross the river undetected. However, they were chased by the British, suffering defeat after defeat. Washington’s leadership began being called into question as they were pushed all the way back the the New Jersey-Pennsylvania border. Never in human history was an army so badly beat but yet was still around to fight another day.

The Beginning of the Revolutionary War & the Siege of Boston

Once someone shot first at Lexington, the much more powerful British army pushed the Americans back to Concord. However, reinforcements arrived for the Americans and, despite being one of the most heavily trained armies on Earth, they were pushed back to Boston, being ambushed by the inexperienced militia forces. Once the British troops were in Boston, the Americans surrounded the position.

Eventually the founding fathers realised that militia forces would not be enough to crush the British so had to organise an army, assigning George Washington to command. George headed north from Philadelphia whilst the British attempted to break the siege, planning to attack the northernly Bunker Hill. Spies warned the newly formed Continental Army of their plans so fortified Bunker Hill and the neighbouring Breeds Hill. The British began the offensive and, after two unsuccessful attempts, the Americans ran out of ammunition and were forced to retreat. The Battle of Bunker Hill was technically a British victory, despite having almost 3 times the casualties of the Continental Army.

A painting of the British charge up Bunker Hill.

However, many Americans were still not decided on what they were fighting for. Some radicals began throwing around independence, whilst others wanted to maintain relations with the British. The latter camp sent a letter to London, requesting the removal of the taxes and an ally ship. George III denied the request. Britain burnt down the towns of Falmouth, MA and Norfolk, VA, which the Americans used to show how brutal the British were. France and Spain, seeing this, sent supplies over to the colonies.

A drawing of Benedict Arnold

Meanwhile, we meet a man called Benedict Arnold. Arnold conducted a plan to take the British fort, Fort Ticonderoga, which had a lot of weapons and ammunition that he believed could be useful for the colony’s war effort. He set off to Ticonderoga by himself, wanting to recruit soldiers along the way. He eventually met the Green Mountain Boys, led by Ethan Allen, who had the same idea as Arnold. After a dispute of who should lead the capture of Ticonderoga, Allen was assigned to lead. Whilst the British were asleep, they took the British by supplies and managed to capture the fort and take the ammunition with little resistance. However, Allen took all the credit of the capture for himself, not even mentioning Arnold. He then attempted to stage an invasion of Canada. The Continental Army had managed to capture Montreal but were pushed back at Quebec, all the way to Fort Ticonderoga.

Henry Knox had an idea of what to do with all the guns and ammo they seized from the British at Ticonderoga. He grabbed some bison and got them to pull the guns and ammo through the harsh winter to Washington’s army in Boston, who very much needed the morale boost. Washington believed that a frontal assault would be necessary to end the siege, but junior officers believed that it would be too risky as they believed the British would be heavily fortified in their position. Thankfully, Washington listened and set up cannons on Dorchester Heights, overlooking the city overnight. Once morning came, the British knew they had no choice but to abandon the city, pulling 9000 soldiers out of the city. Washington had his first victory of the war.

A painting of the cannons being set up at Dorchester Heights

Background Behind The American War of Independence

In 1492, Christopher Columbus, unknowingly, discovered the New World. This New World was rather notorious for having a lot of gold, leading many European countries to set up shop. After many years of waring with each other and the natives, the European powers had gained quite a decent amount of land.

A small strip between Britain and France’s land in the region was disputed by the two sides, until the British sent up-and-comer, George Washington to the region to sort things out. This eventually lead to the Seven Years War between Britain and France.

Britain came out as the victor but at a great monetary cost. In order to get their money back, they decided to tax the American colonies to hell and back. Think of any random every day object and there was probably a tax for it. Stamps? Paper? Sugar? Tea? All taxed

Not only this but the colonies had no representatives in Parliament, despite them being taxed. This is called “Taxation without Representation”, which was drilled into my brain by my Year 11 History teacher.

The Americans ended up boycotting all British goods, meaning Britain was still poor. Eventually, King George had to concede and removed all taxes except for the one on tea and sent 1000 British troops to Boston, forcing the colonists to pay.

On March 5th, 1770, a large group of Colonists came to protest against the soldiers. As back-up arrived for the soldiers, more Colonists arrived and began to throw things at the soldiers, from snowballs to rocks. Eventually, the soldiers had enough, took aim and fired.

A drawing of the Boston Massacre

5 civilians were killed in the massacre. Many Colonial newspapers claimed this was a brutal attack against the colonists and a war crime.

The people were incredibly angered and the violence escalated. Schooners that ran aground would be raided, pro-British politicians would have their houses burnt down and on December 16th, 1773, a group of colonists would disguise themselves as Native Americans, jump onto a shipment of tea and pour it all into the Boston Harbour.

A drawing of the Boston Tea party

In response, the British dissolved their assembly, revoked their charter and sent 3000 more troops to Boston. Boston was now a directly British Occupied City. And the people were angry. Fearing they may be next, other colonies gathered to discuss what to do next

The First Continental Congress. George Washington is depicted central and Benjamin Franklin is in the brown jacket on the left

They decided to politely ask Britain to stop and after they (obviously) said no, they decided to set up groups of soldiers across the 13 colonies, to be ready at a minute’s notice. Hearing this, the British sent out 700 troops into the American Occupied Massachusetts. After setting off to concord in the middle of the night, many Americans were heard to be in the streets yelling “The British are Coming!” The two sides encountered in Lexington. After minutes of yelling, one side shot first. This is considered to be the start of the Revolutionary War.